On Magic, Tricks, and Magic Tricks

By Catherine DiMercurio

There’s something about being in a new relationship in your fifties that leaves you with a whole deck of new thoughts and feelings, which get shuffled around and presented to you, as if some sprite doing the universe’s work is trying out a magic trick. Is this your card?, they say with a flourish. And you study it, trying to figure out if it is, in fact, your card.

What I mean to say is that all new relationships can leave you feeling a little perplexed. After a divorce, no matter how long after, and after other relationships that didn’t work out, no matter how many, when you’re in your fifties and feeling careful and cautious, you don’t immediately believe in the magic part of the magic trick. You’re kind of looking for the trick.

So, this summer, a year after I had reached out to a guy on eharmony and it hadn’t gone anywhere past an initial exchange, he emailed me. I’d had the foresight to give him my email address the prior year, knowing I was about to be done with dating apps. This past August, when I read his email, it took me a minute to connect the dots back to that initial exchange on the app. I then remembered why I had initially reached out: he was a fellow writer, and a professor (I’d joked with my friends about dating a professor. Where’s my professor? I’d ask). It seems he showed up. He also liked some of the same things I did, such as exploring the natural world, hiking. He was a parent, too. There were possibilities here. I had the sense that if I didn’t write back immediately, I would talk myself out of it, and part of me felt like I should give him a chance. I decided to write back before I could change my mind. I was candid about the fact that I was content on my own, and not sure I even wanted to date anymore.

After my last break-up, I had settled into a largely peaceful rhythm that involved following my interests and instincts, enjoying time with family and friends, and reveling in the absence of the particular anxieties my last relationship had wrought upon my heart and brain. Not that this period was angst-free, but when I poked around the notion of what if this is the way it always is—just me and my dog and writing and pottery and family and friends—I was largely okay with that. While I worried that at some point I would wish I had found someone to grow old with, I also was comforted by the idea that alone wasn’t truly something that I’d be, because I have a lot of good people in my life.

Still, I was curious. I suggested that we could email one another and get to know each other that way, as a start. He was agreeable.

We did this for a couple of weeks, and as writers, the format suited us. We sent long missives back and forth on a variety of topics—our pasts, our beliefs, our likes and dislikes, random observations, books, the writing process. It felt like during this period of writing long emails back and forth, we were in a way approximating the feeling of a developing friendship, one that might have taken place in the real world, had we met, say, at a bookstore. I admit though that during this time of correspondence, I was on the lookout for anything I might construe as a red flag, or anything I sensed might spell trouble or be a sign of incompatibility. When I could find none, much to my surprise, I suggested we meet for a hike.

Since that time things have progressed in a way that continues to be dissimilar to any experience I’ve had in the past. He lives over an hour away. There has been little opportunity to just meet for a bite to eat or something, so we squeeze in our time on the weekends. I was finding recently though that I missed the solo down time I used to have on weekends, so I requested we take a weekend off. My ability to make this request speaks volumes. In past relationships, I would have found it very difficult to say something that the other person might perceive as a pulling away or a pushing away. I would have worried that to ask for time for myself would have resulted in their loss of interest. But in this relationship, not only did I feel confident enough of our connection to not worry about my request being misperceived, but I was also keenly aware that I needed this time for myself. I have worked diligently and purposefully toward the goal of being able to recognize and respect myself and my needs, so being able to advocate for myself feels like a necessity, not an option. I know I am a better person and a better partner when I am taking care of myself, not only trying to take care of the relationship. The fact that he received and understood my request without hesitation or negativity was a relief, though not unsurprising when viewed within the context of what I’ve come to know about him.

Still, this is all unfamiliar. It feels healthy and good but the way in which it hasn’t followed the patterns of past relationships has been at times both affirming and unsettling. Hence the aforementioned sprite with the deck of cards and the magic trick. My brain often reverts to questions that seem to assume a norm, a standard. I ask myself: is this how it’s supposed to be (i.e., am I doing this right)? But of course it won’t feel like the past. Not only were there a lot of unhealthy aspects to those past relationships, I am a different person now and am bringing a completely different energy to this relationship. There’s less urgency, less anxiety. I have the sense that we are building something with different tools and materials than what either of us have used in the past. And of course it is going to look and feel different from what other people have; every couple has its unique origin story and history. I love the feeling that we’re building our own story, figuring out the next phase and phrase as we go.

And yes, this is going to mean that at times we pause, looking for the trick. When you’ve had the rug pulled out from under you a couple of times, you tend to be careful of your footing. Or skeptical about the magic trick that seems to be happening in front of your eyes. My instinct is to slow things down, watch mindfully the way it’s all playing out. But sometimes you can’t spot any trickery. Sometimes maybe the magic is just the magic.

Love, Cath